All About Seniors Real Estate
Sunlit landscaped shopping courtyard with mature sycamore, wood benches, and low glass-fronted shops in a Santa Barbara neighborhood.

What La Cumbre Plaza Keeps, and What Goes After 2028

La Cumbre Plaza covers 14.9 acres at State Street and Hope Avenue. Under the plan that moved forward this month, those acres would be split into two parcels. An 8.8-acre lot would hold the Macy's building and most of the parking around it, and that is where new housing would go. The other 6.1 acres would keep the plaza's existing buildings, including Lure Fish House and Pottery Barn.

For anyone in San Roque who runs errands at La Cumbre, that split matters most. The headlines say Macy's is coming down. The plan itself mostly changes the parking lot, while the shops along the walkways stay. Very little changes before 2028.

The shops you walk into stay

Start with the part that stays. The in-line mall is staying, Lure included, according to the Santa Barbara News-Press. The paper also reported that the side of the plaza with Panda Express, See's Candies and Mendocino Farms would remain.

Mendocino Farms is the newest piece of that row. It took over the former Panera Bread space at 3851 State Street. The Restaurant Guy reported on July 7, 2026 that it had opened the week before, and that this location is the chain's 100th. It's open 10:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. daily. A sandwich-and-salad company signed on and opened a new restaurant in the part of the plaza meant to last. Its timing fits the rest of this plan.

The plaza still runs a regular calendar, too. The La Cumbre Center for Creative Arts holds a free Art Walk on Friday, December 18, from 5 to 8 p.m., with wine, beer and snacks across its three galleries. Pinnacle Performance Fitness hosts a dog adoption morning on Saturday, December 5, from 9:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. Both are on the plaza's events page.

Macy's stays open until its lease ends in 2028

Macy's is the plaza's largest building and the one in the news. The store's lease runs until 2028. After that, the developer plans to demolish the building and start construction, with completion expected by 2032. Edhat put the building at about 141,440 square feet. Noozhawk reported that the building dates to 1967 and that in January 2025 the city found it had no historical significance and could be torn down.

So the store you know will keep its doors open for at least another year and more. The big change at Hope and State is still years away. The November hearing moved the plan for that change a step forward.

What the board advanced on November 9

On Monday, November 9, the city's Architectural Board of Review and its staff hearing officer held a seven-hour hearing on the project. The board voted 3-1 to move it forward. The News-Press noted that many design details still have to be worked out.

The project sits at 3805 State Street and 110 South Hope Avenue. The owner is Matthew Taylor, through MCP Santa Barbara LLC, according to Noozhawk. "This is my backyard. I grew up coming to this plaza," Taylor told the News-Press.

Edhat described the project this way:

  • Six buildings, two to six stories tall
  • 680 apartments: 94 studios, 383 one-bedrooms, 186 two-bedrooms and 17 three-bedrooms
  • 54 income-restricted units, 39 for very-low-income households and 15 for moderate-income households
  • About 27,947 square feet of commercial space
  • 817 residential parking spaces and 107 commercial spaces, in two levels of underground parking plus two ground-level garages
  • More than 750 bicycle parking spaces
  • About 60,916 square feet of open space and plazas

The city's project page for The Neighborhood at State & Hope describes the homes as a mix of market-rate and income-restricted rentals. The commercial space is a small fraction of what's there now: under 28,000 square feet of new shops and services, compared with a 141,440-square-foot department store. The new space would sit inside a residential complex rather than in a single anchor store.

The asphalt becomes front doors

The parking lot is where most residents will see the change, more than the Macy's building. The Macy's building and the parking areas around it would be demolished for the housing, and the new buildings would go up on that land.

At the hearing, project planner Gelare Macon said that when the mall was built in the 1960s, "it was a place you drove to." She added, as the News-Press reported, "Where there's asphalt now, there will be front doors."

Edhat lists more site details. The plan removes 137 trees on the property and 14 street trees, all replaced with new plantings. The residential buildings would be all-electric, with no natural gas. The State Street bus stop would move to a spot next to the new development. If you ride the bus from upper State to La Cumbre, plan on a new stop location once construction starts.

Parking came up at the hearing too. Attorney Brad Lundgren represents the owners of the buildings that are staying. He told the board his clients do not oppose the project, but they want the planned loss of parking and a proposed bike lane addressed, since both could affect customers. "These conditions need to be addressed," he said, as reported by the News-Press. Board member Richard Six cast the dissenting vote and told the News-Press the project is "too massive and not in proportion to the neighborhood."

Those comments point to where the remaining design work is likely to focus: how much parking the shops that stay will have, and what the buildings look like from State Street.

The Sears side runs on its own clock

A second housing proposal covers the opposite side of La Cumbre Plaza, on the former Sears building and its parking lot at 3845 State Street. The two projects have separate developers who are not working together. A plan to coordinate the whole area fell apart in 2022.

Riviera Dairy owns the Sears property. It is working with Kennedy Wilson, the Orange County developer that built the nearby Estancia homes on State Street. Their proposal is 443 rental apartments plus a garage and surface lot with 466 parking spaces. It also includes a multiuse path along Arroyo Burro Creek on the east side of the property, according to Noozhawk's November 2025 coverage. The Architectural Board of Review was highly critical of the design at that review, and the development team planned to come back with changes later.

So the plaza's two big boxes are on separate schedules. The Macy's side now has a lease end date and a target completion date. The Sears side does not have firm dates yet. The city keeps a project page for 3845 State Street for anyone who wants to follow it.

A calendar for the next six years

Here is how the dates line up from this month through 2032:

  1. December 2026: The plaza's regular events continue, including the December 5 dog adoption morning and the December 18 Art Walk.
  2. Through 2028: Macy's stays open while design details for the replacement project are finalized.
  3. After the 2028 lease end: Demolition of the Macy's building and construction on the 8.8-acre parcel, with the State Street bus stop moving.
  4. By 2032: Expected completion of the 680 apartments.
  5. Sears side, no firm dates: The development team plans to return to the review board with a revised design.

Through all of it, Lure, Pottery Barn, See's, Panda Express and Mendocino Farms are on the 6.1 acres that stay.

Our earlier look at San Roque's long-vacant storefront on upper State reopening showed a similar pattern. On this stretch of upper State, change tends to come on dates fixed well ahead of time, by leases and permits.

A change to the places you shop can raise a quiet question for an older homeowner or an adult child: does our daily routine still work from this house? If that question is on your mind, All About Seniors talks through it at our free community sessions, with no pressure and at your own pace. You can see what's coming up on our senior seminar schedule. Attend a Free Senior Seminar, and bring your questions about where the next few years will take you.

Work With the Best in the Industry

Discover the methods I use to deliver exceptional service to every client. Contact me today to start your home searching journey!

Follow Me on Instagram